Which Catholic High School?
Parent Q&A
Select any title to view the full question and replies.
LGBTQIA friendly Catholic high school?
–Oct 9, 2023We are considering Bishop O’Dowd and Saint Mary’s high school and wondering how supportive they are of students who identify as gay/lesbian/bisexual? We can’t find much on their websites and the local news has published some concerning articles lately. We’re hoping to hear directly from some families. Thank you!
Oct 9, 2023St Marys College HS or Bishop O'Dowd HS
–Sep 9, 2019Hi parents of kids older than mine - we are zoned for a public high school that we are not super interested in, so we are applying to both O'Dowd and St Mary's. We like both schools but get a very different feel from each of them. Neither we parents nor our child have a preference (yet) and we are not sure how to select the best one. We have attended various events at both schools and will continue to do so in the fall. Our child is very focused academically (especially math and science) and is an athlete. We are not Catholic - in fact we are really not religious at all. We parents are agnostic and we have not raised our kids with any religious focus - but we are not at all opposed to our children learning about Catholicism and religion in general. In fact we love the emphasis on ethics and self-discovery, and service learning.
If your family is like ours, we are curious about your (recent) experience with how it feels to be a part of a religious community at one of these high schools. Can you be yourself? Do you feel respected? Does your child feel welcomed and included? Pressured to conform? etc.
Did your family struggle with the choice between these 2 schools? Which school did you choose, and how happy are you with your choice? What helped you and your child decide?
We are trying not to be too swayed by the inevitable focus on where close friends are going.
Thanks.
Sep 9, 2019Bishop O'Dowd vs St. Mary's?
–Feb 11, 2019We are applying to Catholic Schools this fall and are looking at BOD and St. Mary's as our top two choices. I am wondering what the major differences are between these two schools from people who have had experience with both of them? We are a Jewish family with an artsy son who isn't into sports, but would be interested in theater, debate and vocal music. He shadowed both and liked them equally. Anyone have experience with both and able to compare the two? Thank you.
Feb 11, 2019
There have been some concerning stores, particularly about one school (not mentioned here). I understand and totally sympathize with your concern. For reference, I am Catholic, have/had kids at Catholic schools, and am a huge believer in/supporter of Catholic education for all kids. I also believe in the inherent dignity and worth of every person, no matter their sexual orientation, as do the vast majority of Catholics.
That said, O'Dowd is a diocesan school, and as such, falls under the governance of the diocese and the Bishop of Oakland. I would not describe this diocese (unlike the archdiocese of SF) as particularly conservative, but diocesan schools do have to abide by directives that come from this hierarchy. Whether or not a bishop chooses to make anything in particular a directive or an issue is up to them, but schools are generally are expected to be in line with what comes from the diocese.
In contrast, St. Mary's College High School is not a diocesan school and is run by the Christian Brothers of De La Salle, or Lasallians. (To digress, the Lasallians are a fantastic order and have the most amazing educational reach/philosophy - worth reading up on - check out Christo Rey De La Salle High School in Oakland for example). I have had kids at both diocesan and Lasallian schools. If my child identified as you were describing, I would not hesitate to send them to St. Mary's. Our student attended there, and had a great many friends who identified as queer, trans and more, and it was NEVER an issue with anyone in the administration, teaching staff, student body, etc.
Best of luck to you!